Eminent Domain Dispute Erupts in Fulton County

Rural landscape in Fulton County, highlighting areas affected by eminent domain.

Article Sponsored by:

Northford Structural Connections (NSC)

Northford Structural Connections (NSC) specializes in innovative engineering solutions for enhancing the safety and durability of precast concrete structures. Their patented products, including the Double-Tee Flexible Connection (DTFC) and Double-Tee Connection Pro (DTC Pro), address critical challenges like fatigue, corrosion, and seismic resilience. With a focus on quality and longevity, NSC provides advanced connection systems trusted by industry professionals for both retrofitting and new construction projects.

News Summary

A recent ruling in Fulton County has ignited tensions regarding property rights and eminent domain, as Sandersville Railroad seeks to acquire land for a new railroad project. The case highlights the concerns of local landowners, spurred by a judge’s decision allowing the railroad to proceed with its controversial Hanson Spur Project despite appeals from affected residents and legal challenges from advocacy groups. This situation reflects ongoing debates about the limits of eminent domain, particularly in favor of private interests.

Eminent Domain Case in Fulton County: Landowners Fight Back

A recent ruling in Fulton County Superior Court has resulted in a heated battle over the rights of property owners and the power of eminent domain, sparking concerns over land acquisition by private entities. The case centers on the Sandersville Railroad Company, which has been granted the authority to seize land from multiple property owners in middle Georgia for a project it claims will benefit the community.

Judge Upholds Ruling Amid Ongoing Appeals

Judge Craig Schwall upheld a decision that allows Sandersville Railroad to exert eminent domain power to acquire properties owned by individuals such as Diane Smith, who expressed relief that construction has yet to commence, but remains anxious about the prospect of losing her land. This ruling came after the Institute for Justice (IJ), representing the property owners, announced plans to appeal directly to the Supreme Court of Georgia.

The Rationale Behind the Project

Sandersville Railroad is pursuing a 4.5-mile spur called the Hanson Spur Project, aimed at linking raw material producers to the CSX Transportation rail line. The Georgia Public Service Commission (PSC) deemed that this railway expansion represents a legitimate public use, thus allowing the condemnation process to proceed.

A Longstanding Family Legacy at Stake

The case initially erupted in March 2023 when Sandersville Railroad requested permission to condemn land owned by the Garrett family, who had held their land for generations. Facing pressure from the railroad, the Garretts, along with other property owners, sought legal assistance from the IJ in May 2023.

Following the emergence of additional property owners joining the lawsuit, Sandersville Railroad sought condemnation of further lands in July 2023. By September 2024, the PSC unanimously endorsed the railroad’s request, paving the way for the current legal struggles.

Legal Experts Weigh In on Eminent Domain

Amid this legal tussle, the IJ’s attorney argued that a private railroad’s endeavor for the advantage of private parties does not meet the public use criteria set forth under both U.S. and Georgia law. They highlighted the case’s potential to escalate to the U.S. Supreme Court, especially given the high-profile Kelo v. City of New London decision from 2005 regarding the use of eminent domain for economic development.

Atlanta’s Proactive Stance on Blight

In a separate yet similar matter, Atlanta’s Mayor Andre Dickens is spearheading an initiative to combat chronic blight throughout the city. The Atlanta City Council has unanimously supported a resolution urging the mayor’s administration to employ eminent domain to address neglected residential and commercial properties, focusing particularly on large multifamily dwellings.

This measure comes in light of longstanding issues related to absentee landlords and the negative impact of blighted properties, which have been linked to crime and health hazards. Complementing this initiative, a blight tax has been introduced, increasing property taxes on owners of such properties until improvements are made.

The Urgency of Action

Mayor Dickens emphasized the necessity of addressing blighted properties swiftly, stating that the city can no longer afford to wait for owners to remedy the situation themselves. With the ongoing efforts to bolster the code enforcement unit, which was significantly depleted during the pandemic, the aim is to restore appropriate staffing levels to tackle these issues more effectively.

Aiming for Affordable Housing Solutions

In tandem with the blight initiative, Mayor Dickens has set a goal to create 20,000 affordable housing units by 2030, with a specific focus on vacant homes owned by institutional investors. This strategy is expected to address the substantial number of vacant properties that remain a blight on the community.

Challenges Ahead for Eminent Domain

Despite the city’s legal framework supporting condemnation, experts warn that the application of eminent domain may face significant legal challenges, particularly if property owners can demonstrate that they are not willfully neglectful or if ownership disputes arise. Under Georgia law, the city must prove in court that a blighted property presents risks to both itself and surrounding properties to move forward with condemnation.

With these legal battles unfolding on two fronts—one in Fulton County and the other in Atlanta—the ongoing discourse surrounding eminent domain rights remains a contentious issue, touching the lives of property owners and the future of their communities.